

In 2022, American Idol viewers voted HunterGirl into second place. Now HunterGirl is engaged to Nashville songwriter and musician Warren Garrett, and this time the only vote that counted was hers.

The season 20 runner-up, born Hunter Wolkonowski in Winchester, Tennessee, announced it on Instagram on Sunday 15 November 2026 with three photos. Garrett posted his own the same day, and neither has said how long they have been a couple.
“the easiest yes of my life. can’t wait to spend forever with you,” she wrote, in lower case, signing off with a dove and a white heart.
His caption went one line further.
“She said yes! I love you to the stars and back. Also, I know. I way out kicked my coverage,” Garrett wrote on Instagram.
It is American football slang, and it means he knows he is lucky.
Garrett was born and raised in upstate South Carolina and moved to Nashville to make music, according to his Melodies n Memories podcast episode.
In April 2017, he tagged her handle, @hntrgrl1031, in a post inviting fans to an afternoon set at Rippy’s in Nashville. It shows a shared bill and nothing more.
His name is on her record, too. The Tennessee Girl tracklist credits him as a co-writer of track three, “Weather in Tennessee”, alongside HunterGirl, Joybeth Taylor and Gabe Foust.
The EP, her label debut, came out on 7 June 2024. PopCulture reports the two have been writing songs together since early 2024.
So before the ring, there was a song.
In February, she teased People about a new man in her life. It was Pippin, her Shih Tzu, who begs for sweet potatoes every day.
Look closely at the first and third of her three photos. EntertainmentNow describes an oval-cut centre diamond set in a delicate halo of smaller diamonds.

The jeweller, carat weight and metal are not public.
For another celebrity oval, Aryna Sabalenka’s custom ring is among our favourite engagement rings from recently engaged celebrities, alongside this year’s other celebrity engagements.
iHeart names Priscilla Block, Tigirlily Gold and Madeline Merlo among the artists who congratulated her. Block had shared her own engagement photos a day earlier.
If you missed her season, judge Luke Bryan once called her the “new-age Miranda Lambert”. She finished second to Noah Thompson in the season 20 finale on 22 May 2022.
Four years on, the applause is for something else.
How or where he proposed has not been shared, and there is no wedding date or venue yet. For now, the moment is theirs, told in three photos and two captions.
They wrote a song before they set a date. If your own date and venue are still unwritten, Wedded Concierge plans and books it end to end, with venues and suppliers from the Wedded Marketplace.
Second place in 2022 was the viewers’ call. The easiest yes of her life was hers alone.
Written by

Content and Creative Manager | Wonder Group
Joseph Joshua is the SEO & Content Manager at Wedded Wonderland, bringing an editorial and search strategy perspective to the publication’s coverage of luxury weddings, destination celebrations and bridal lifestyle. His approach to content centres on helping readers move from inspiration to informed decisions, with attention to the design, craftsmanship and personal details that give a celebration its character.
Search real weddings, venues and vendors from around the world.
Search Wedded Wonderland